Matching DNA to a diet doesn’t work: ‘We didn’t even come close,’ researcher says
By Sharon Begley, STAT | 02. 20. 2018
DNA testing won’t guide dieters to the weight-loss regimen most likely to work for them, scientists reported on Tuesday. Despite some earlier studies claiming that genetic variants predict whether someone has a better chance of shedding pounds on a low-carbohydrate or a low-fat diet, and despite a growing industry premised on that notion, the most rigorous study so far found no difference in weight loss between overweight people on diets that “matched” their genotype and those on diets that didn’t.
The findings make it less likely that genetics might explain why only some people manage to lose weight on a low-carb diet like Atkins and why others succeed with a low-fat one (even though the vast majority of dieters don’t keep off whatever pounds they lose). Unlike cancer treatments, diets can’t be matched to genotype, the new study shows.
The results underline “how, for most people, knowing genetic risk information doesn’t have a big impact,” said Timothy Caulfield, of the University of Alberta, a critic of quackery. “We know weight loss is tough and sustained weight loss is even...
Related Articles
In late April, news broke that police used a public genealogy database to identify a suspect in the “Golden State Killer” case. Police accessed a website where individuals share their genetic test results in hopes of finding family members, but used a pseudonym to upload data from a rape kit. Extensive news coverage of the investigation raised questions about privacy and the ethics of using consumers’ own shared data (rather than police databases) for law enforcement purposes.
This...
By Gina Maranto, Guest Contributor | 06.04.2018
Taking Baby Steps, Jody Lyneé Madeira’s recently published investigation of what she terms the “infertility journey,” joins a host of other scholarly works that explore what happens to and around people who opt to use reproductive medicine in an attempt to have children. Madeira’s mixed-method research approach has yielded in-depth material on how people make decisions under stress about their treatment, as well as revealing overarching themes regarding the patient-physician relationship and the attitudes and behaviors of women and...
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is beginning to move against dubious stem-cell clinics, and not a moment too soon.
The U.S. Department of Justice, on behalf of the FDA, filed lawsuits on May 9 seeking permanent injunctions against two of the most prominent stem cell clinics, one in California and one in Florida. The FDA last August seized a potentially life-threatening virus from California Stem Cell Treatment Centers, which had combined it with stem cells and injected it into...
On May 6, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) opened national enrollment for the All of Us Research Program. This was the biggest step yet in what was originally called the Precision Medicine Initiative that President Obama announced in January 2015; the name was changed in October 2016. The goal remains to collect genetic and health data from a million volunteers; the projected completion date is 2022.
Concerns about the project were raised as soon as it was announced, and...
