Lisa Ikemoto Guest Piece on Human Germline Genetic Modification
By Lisa C. Ikemoto,
Knoepfler Lab Stem Cell Blog
| 03. 23. 2015
Untitled Document
I have been following the reports about genetic editing technology with concern. The fact that some scientists are calling for moratoria on gene editing of human embryos heartens me. Frankly, I had little confidence that any group of scientists could bring themselves to call for limits on research. The call for a moratorium is as much a game changer as the technology itself. It creates an opportunity for research transparency and open exchange between the scientific community and the lay public. Germline modification raises a wide range of scientific, social and ethical issues that we have only begun to consider. The call for a moratorium puts those issues front and center and, if implemented, gives us valuable time for consideration.
In the meantime, as Paul Knoepfler has pointed out, we need is a practical plan for proceeding. His ABCD plan proposes use of SCROs for approval and oversight of in vitro research. The use of existing oversight mechanisms makes sense, although in practice, both IRB and SCRO review is only as rigorous as local institutional culture allows. SCRO...
Related Articles
By Jackie Davalos, Bloomberg | 09.15.2025
Kindbody, one of the largest fertility companies in the US, sought to disrupt egg freezing and IVF by combining spa vibes with Silicon Valley efficiency. The startup raised millions, opened dozens of clinics, and became a billion-dollar unicorn. But its...
By Holly Baxter, The Independent | 08.19.2025
In rural Pennsylvania, I’m hiking through the forest with Simone and Malcom Collins and discussing the executive order they wrote for Donald Trump. Just outside their house — beyond the chicken coop, where they gather their eggs for homemade cakes...
By Grace Tobin and Kirsten Robb, ABC News Australia | 09.01.2025
A secret audit of a major fertility clinic revealed that almost all of its donor sperm being provided to patients was at high risk of potential mix-ups.
The Queensland Fertility Group (QFG), which is owned by Australia's largest IVF company...
By Grace Tobin and Kirsten Robb, ABC News Australia | 08.31.2025
A biracial baby was born to a white couple in Brisbane in an IVF mix-up that Australia's biggest fertility company kept secret for the past 11 years.
The incident has never been made public before, but ABC Investigations has learned...