Substituting genetic ancestry for race in research? Not so fast
By Anna C. F. Lewis,
STAT
| 05. 02. 2022
Race, widely used as a variable across biomedical research and medicine, is an appropriate proxy for racism — but not for anything biological. Proposals to use genetic ancestry instead of race are at risk of perpetuating the same problems.
Dozens of algorithms widely used in clinical care contain an adjustment factor for a patient’s race. When estimating kidney function, for example, different results are returned depending on whether the patient’s race is entered as “Black” or “non-Black,” though at least for kidney function the use of race is being challenged. Some medications have been approved only for those of certain self-identified racial groups. Meanwhile in research, the race of participants is routinely considered at almost every step of the research process — from recruitment to analysis to the interpretation of findings.
Race-based health disparities have reinvigorated the debate about whether these uses of race are appropriate, and their potential connection to racism.
To be sure, race is an important variable to track in order to understand the social drivers of health, including the impact of racism. But it... see more
Related Articles
By John Anderson, The Wall Street Journal | 05.10.2022
“Our Father,” Netflix.
A horror story presented as too much of a horror movie, “Our Father” features interviews with the offspring of fertility doctor Donald Cline, but certainly not all of them. Beginning in 1979, Dr. Cline, by his own...
By Kevin Davies, Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology News | 05.18.2022
WASHINGTON, DC — In his current role as President Biden’s acting scientific advisor, Francis Collins, MD, PhD, is dealing with a wide range of issues from semiconductor shortages to wildfires. “But my heart is in what you are all doing...
By David Jensen, The California Stem Cell Report | 05.20.2022
Photo by Giorgio Trovato on Unsplash
The directors of the $12 billion California stem cell agency are looking for a new chair who is both decisive and collaborative, passionate and inclusive. But at the top of the wish list is...
By Joanna Thompson, Scientific American | 05.18.2022
Imagine taking a genetic test that could tell you your personal risk of developing complications and dying from a particular disease, such as cancer, heart attack or even COVID. A version of such a test exists—albeit an imperfect one.
Genome-wide...