New Three-Parent Baby Law ‘is Flawed and Open to Challenge’, says Senior Lawyer
By Steve Connor,
The Independent [UK]
| 01. 14. 2015
Untitled Document
The Government’s attempt to legalise so-called “three parent” babies is open to challenge by judicial review because of serious flaws in the proposed legislation, a senior lawyer has warned.
Legislation to allow mitochondrial donation is either unnecessary or invalid under the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act, according to international law expert Lord Brennan QC.
The written opinion, which has been passed to parliamentary authorities, says there are “significant doubts” about the legality of proposed regulations being introduced by the Department of Health.
Lord Brennan states: “If the regulations are approved in their current form, they may be open to challenge by way of judicial review.”
The Government has introduced new regulations to allow mitochondrial donation – where genetic material of two women’s eggs is merged with a man’s sperm, to ensure women with mitochondrial defects do not pass on mutations to their children – because it was thought that the controversial IVF technique was specifically banned under the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008.
The Act defines a “permitted” egg or embryo as one whose “nuclear or mitochondrial...
Related Articles
By Megan Molteni and Anil Oza, STAT | 10.07.2025
For two years, a panel of scientific experts, clinicians, and patient advocates had been hammering out ways to increase community engagement in National Institutes of Health-funded science. When they presented their road map to the NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya last...
By Shoumita Dasgupta, STAT | 10.03.2025
President Trump and health secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. have characterized the rise in autism diagnoses in recent years as an epidemic requiring emergency intervention.
This approach is factually wrong: The broadening definition of autism and the improvement in diagnosis...
By Abby McCloskey, The Dallas Morning News | 10.10.2025
We Texans like to do things our way — leave some hide on the fence rather than stay corralled, as goes a line in Wallace O. Chariton’s Texas dictionary This Dog’ll Hunt. Lately, I’ve been wondering what this ethos...
Paula Amato & Shoukhrat Mitalipov
[OHSU News/Christine Torres Hicks]
On September 30th, a team of 21 scientists from Oregon Health & Science University (OHSU) published a significant paper in Nature Communications, with a scientifically accurate but, to many, somewhat abstruse headline:
Induction of experimental cell division to generate cells with reduced chromosome ploidy
The lead authors were Shoukhrat Mitalipov, recently described here as “a push-the-envelope biologist,” and his long-term colleague Paula Amato. (Recall that in July the pair had co-published with...
