Four Problems with the DNA Database
By Sharon Fernandes,
Times of India
| 08. 02. 2015
Untitled Document
India's Human DNA Profiling Bill 2015 proposes to set up a national DNA database of criminals that will include rapists, murderers and kidnappers. But the proposed draft is being criticized on several grounds — from being insensitive to privacy issues to allowing intrusive modes of sample collection.
The draft has been drawn up by the Department of Biotechnology in association with an autonomous institution, the Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics (CDFD) and has been in the works for 12 years. But international activist groups monitoring developments in genetic technologies like GeneWatch UK, Council for Responsible Genetics, USA and online collectives like The Forensic Genetics Policy Initiative (FGPI) say it doesn't have enough safeguards built into it.
Too large and sweeping
The DNA databank, as visualized in the draft bill, will have six categories, ranging from suspects to missing persons (see box). The offenders' index in the final bill may even encompass minor crimes such as the MV (Motor Vehicles) Act offences.
"Making the database too big and poorly regulated will not help solve more crimes," says Helen...
Related Articles
By Yelena Biberman and Jonathan D. Moreno, Bioethics Forum | 04.16.2024
A quiet biological revolution in warfare is underway. The genome is emerging as a new domain of conflict. The level of destruction that only nuclear weapons could previously achieve is fast becoming as accessible as a cyberattack.
Now for the...
By Jorge Barrera and Rachel Houlihan, CBC | 04.09.2024
A Canadian DNA laboratory knowingly delivered prenatal paternity test results that routinely identified the wrong biological fathers — ruling out the real dads — and left a trail of shattered lives around the globe, a CBC News investigation has found...
By Timnit Gebru and Émile P. Torres, First Monday | 04.14.2024
The stated goal of many organizations in the field of artificial intelligence (AI) is to develop artificial general intelligence (AGI), an imagined system with more intelligence than anything we have ever seen. Without seriously questioning whether such a system can...
By Carey Gillan, UnSpun | 03.18.2024
A Mexican standoff with the United States turned into a Mexican smack-down this month with the release of Mexico’s formal rebuttal to US efforts to overturn limits Mexico has ordered on the use of genetically modified (GM) corn and the...