Disability Community and Identity: Perceptions of Prenatal Screening
By Deborah Kaplan and Marsha Saxton,
Excerpt from Our Bodies Ourselves (2005 edition)
| 11. 30. 2004
People with disabilities come to the genetic screening debate from a perspective that perplexes many scientists and medical professionals. We are purportedly the ones helped by genetic advances, yet we are critical of much of the research. Those with disabilities who have lived their lives creatively managing the logistics of a disability, as well as fighting disability discrimination, may regard the new genetic "options" as a way to promote selective abortion. In an attempt to "eliminate disability," medical science may harbor motivations that spur the prenatal technologies in the direction of eliminating disabled people before they are born rather than addressing fundamental social causes of disability discrimination and the resulting lowered socio-economic status of citizens with disabilities.
This article explores the social origins of disability discrimination and its implications for prenatal diagnosis, and examines some of the objections to screening expressed by people with disabilities.
Definitions of Disability
Disability policy scholars describe four different historical and social models of disability: (1) A moral model of disability which regards disability as the result of sin; (2) A medical model of disability... see more
Related Articles
By Adam Rutherford, The Guardian | 06.19.2022
Photo by Ante Samarzija on Unsplash
It’s a quirk of history that the foundations of modern biology – and as a consequence, some of the worst atrocities of the 20th century – should rely so heavily on peas. Cast your...
By The Japan Times, The Japan Times | 05.30.2022
Photo by Roméo A. on Unsplash
Japan will undergo a policy review by the U.N. Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities in late August following a two-year delay due to the coronavirus pandemic, sources close to the matter...
A Eugenics Society poster (1930s) from the
Wellcome Library Eugenics Society Archive via Wikimedia
On a Saturday afternoon in May, Payton S. Gendron shot 13 people, almost all Black, at a supermarket in Buffalo, killing 10. This was hardly an isolated incident: It was one of over 200 mass shootings so far this year. Only 10 days later, at least 21 people died in a school shooting at Uvalde, Texas. That killer was apparently a lonely, bullied 18-year-old with a...
By Kevin Davies, Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology News | 05.18.2022
WASHINGTON, DC — In his current role as President Biden’s acting scientific advisor, Francis Collins, MD, PhD, is dealing with a wide range of issues from semiconductor shortages to wildfires. “But my heart is in what you are all doing...