Prisoners and Clinical Trials
By Osagie K. Obasogie,
Genetic Crossroads
| 06. 29. 2007
Cruel and Unusual Ethics?
Much ink has been spilled over the Institute of Medicine's (IOM) recent recommendation to loosen federal restrictions on using prisoners as human subjects in medical research. Supporters point to the pharmaceutical and biomedical industry's growing need for participants in clinical trials, and to changing values among ethicists regarding autonomy and informed consent. Opponents highlight the legacy of past abuses and the likelihood that they will be repeated.
The Department of Health and Human Services commissioned the Institute of Medicine to "review the ethics regarding research involving prisoners . . . to explore whether [past] conclusions . . . remain appropriate today." Though the IOM makes several suggestions, the rubber meets the road in its recommendation to shift from the policy put in place in the 1970s, which severely limits clinical trials in prisons, to a more subjective risk/benefit analysis.
To justify this recommendation, the IOM changes the ethical framework governing prisoner participation as human subjects. The current framework, crafted to prevent repetitions of the serious abuses of past years, prioritizes justice - ensuring that prisoners are treated fairly in terms...
Related Articles
By Miranda Bryant, The Guardian | 08.27.2025
Denmark’s prime minister, Mette Frederiksen, has apologised for the first time for the forced contraception scandal in which thousands of Greenlandic girls and women were fitted with contraceptive coils without their permission or knowledge.
Describing it as “systemic discrimination” against...
By Caroline Kitchener, The New York Times | 08.21.2025
Less than two weeks after an Alabama Supreme Court decision upended in vitro fertilization in the state and prompted a national backlash, over 100 conservative congressional staff members and I.V.F. skeptics crammed into a meeting room a few blocks from...
By Roni Caryn Rabin, The New York Times | 08.25.2025
Scientists have dreamed for centuries about using animal organs to treat ailing humans. In recent years, those efforts have begun to bear fruit: Researchers have begun transplanting the hearts and kidneys of genetically modified pigs into patients, with varying degrees...
By Annika Inampudi, Science | 08.01.2025
In June, Sara* received a message asking whether she wanted to continue to participate in a massive, multicenter research project led by scientists at Aarhus University in Denmark. The iPsych study, the message said, had sequenced her genetic data from...