Editorial: Stem cell fallout
By Sacramento Bee,
Sacramento Bee
| 01. 20. 2006
The fraud perpetrated by South Korean scientist Hwang Woo-Suk is a setback for regenerative medicine, but it also serves as a rich learning opportunity for California's $3 billion stem cell research institute.
For the last two months, leaders of the California Institute of Regenerative Medicine have resisted calls to publicly review the South Korea scandal and ensure that its ethics standards are adequate to avoid similar misdeeds. Now we know why.
As it turns out, an ethics adviser for the California institute, Jose Cibelli, co-authored a 2004 paper by Hwang that has been under suspicion for weeks and now has been shown to include fabricated data. Michigan State University, where Cibelli works, is investigating Cibelli's role in co-authoring the 2004 paper, in which Hwang made a monumental claim - now discredited - to have cloned a human embryo and extracted stem cells from it.
After inquiries from this page, the California institute disclosed Wednesday that Cibelli will not be advising the institute while the investigation continues.
"Until that issue is resolved, Cibelli has voluntarily withdrawn from his activities on the...
Related Articles
By Deni Ellis Béchard, The Washington Post | 10.07.2025
In 1949, when John Gurdon was a 16-year-old boarding school student at Eton College in England, his teacher described his biology studies as “disastrous” and his scientific ambitions as “ridiculous.”
“If he can’t learn simple biological facts,” his term report...
By John H. Evans, Craig Callender, Neal K. Devaraj, Farren J. Isaacs, and Gregory E. Kaebnick, Issues in Science and Technology | 07.04.2025
The controversy around a ban on “mirror life” should lead to a more nuanced public conversation about how to manage the benefits and risks of precursor biotechnologies.
About five years ago, the five of us formed a discussion group to...
Riquet Mammoth Kakao (c.1920)
by Ludwig Hohlwein, Public Domain via Flickr
Colossal, the de-extinction company, scored headlines (1, 2, 3, 4, 5) recently by announcing that they had created mice! Not just any mice, not even colossal mice, but genetically engineered, normal-size “woolly mice” that are the result of editing seven genes in mouse embryos. This Colossal presented as an important step toward making a specimen of charismatic megafauna – a...
By Antonio Regalado, MIT Technology Review | 05.06.2024
It was a cool morning at the beef teaching unit in Gainesville, Florida, and cow number #307 was bucking in her metal cradle as the arm of a student perched on a stool disappeared into her cervix. The arm held...
