Dark History, Bright Future?: The Ethical Conundrum of Eugenics and Genomics
By Alexander Capron
| 04. 26. 2007
A talk given at the ESRC Genome Policy and Research Forum at the University of Edinburgh, Scotland
It is a cliché to suggest that we are standing at the edge of a new age, but in terms of genetic science, that cliché is an understatement. Just as the great gains in theory and methodology achieved by physicists early in the 20th century produced both an exponential growth in understanding and applications of that knowledge that transformed human affairs, so the work of genetic researchers in the last decade of the 20th century set the stage for what I am sure we all agree will be equally astonishing theoretical and practical transformations in biology in this century.
There has, of course, been a great deal of hype as well. The tendency to claim "breakthrough" for every research finding, especially those related to grave human diseases, is visible on a daily basis in the media, as well as in more scientific settings. This tendency, which is born both of intellectual excitement and simple pride, driven as well by the competition for research funding and by the imperatives of University publicity departments, carries the potential for backlash.
Yet, even if...
Related Articles
By Grace Won, KQED [with CGS' Katie Hasson] | 12.02.2025
In the U.S., it’s illegal to edit genes in human embryos with the intention of creating a genetically engineered baby. But according to the Wall Street Journal, Bay Area startups are focused on just that. It wouldn’t be the first...
By Emma Cieslik, Ms. Magazine | 11.20.2025
Several recent Biopolitical Times posts (1, 2, 3, 4) have called attention to the alarmingly rapid commercialization of “designer baby” technologies: polygenic embryo screening (especially its use to purportedly screen for traits like intelligence), in vitro gametogenesis (lab-made eggs and sperm), and heritable genome editing (also termed embryo editing or reproductive gene editing). Those three, together with artificial wombs, have been dubbed the “Gattaca stack” by Brian Armstrong, CEO of the cryptocurrency company...
Alice Wong, founder of the Disability Visibility Project, MacArthur Genius, liberationist, storyteller, writer, and friend of CGS, died on November 14. Alice shone a bright light on pervasive ableism in our society. She articulated how people with disabilities are limited not by an inability to do things but by systemic segregation and discrimination, the de-prioritization of accessibility, and the devaluation of their lives.
We at CGS learned so much from Alice about disability justice, which goes beyond rights...