Ethical Issues in New Uses of Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis
By Edgar Dahl,
Human Reproduction
| 06. 01. 2003
Vol.18, No. 7
[Editor's note: In this brief article,
German bioethicist Edgar Dahl raises and dismisses five objections
to the future use of embryo screening to choose the sexual orientation
of children. He does not mention any evidence for, or controversy
about, a "gay gene," but concludes that if a "safe
and reliable genetic test" for sexual orientation were
to become available, "parents should clearly be allowed"
to use it, as long as they are permitted to select for homosexual
as well as heterosexual children. Dahl has previously argued
that PGD should be allowed for sex selection for social reasons.]
Should parents be allowed to use preimplantation
genetic diagnosis to choose the sexual orientation of their
children?
Extending the application of preimplantation genetic
diagnosis (PGD) to screen embryos for non-medical traits such
as gender, height and intelligence, raises serious moral, legal,
and social issues. In this paper I consider the possibility
of using PGD to select the sexual orientation of offspring.
After considering five potential objections, I conclude that
parents should be permitted to use PGD to choose...
Related Articles
By Anna Collinson and Jo Adnitt, BBC | 08.18.2026
At least 30 children, most of them British, are feared to have been conceived by IVF treatment in northern Cyprus using the wrong sperm or egg donors.
In each case, the parents suspect they did not get the donors they...
What We Inherit by Sam Trejo and Daphne O. Martschenko; and Original Sin by Kathryn Paige Harden have a great deal in common, with substantial differences in style and emphasis. Both books attempt, in different ways, to show the reader just where current research into human genomics stands, where that might be going, and why the authors are interested. In short, the influence of genomic research on our societies is already large and seems likely to change them in ways...
By Dan Falk, Nautilus | 08.20.2026
The pseudoscience of eugenics, founded on the mistaken notion that nature envisions some “right” combination of genes, and that selective breeding can improve the human race, is making a comeback. While the heyday of eugenics was a century ago, the...
By Emily Packard Dawson and Lainie Friedman Ross, MedPage Today | 08.18.2026
Few things evoke a greater sense of desperation than a parent seeking an experimental treatment for their child. That desperation can make even extraordinary risks seem worth taking. This dynamic has come into stark relief after Mei, a 6-year-old girl...
