The Right to Genetic Ignorance
By Editorial,
New Scientist
| 09. 06. 2013
The age of genomic medicine is dawning. Whole-genome sequencing is starting to transform the diagnosis of rare inherited diseases, and within a few decades it could be a routine part of medical care (see "
Your genomic future: Personalised medicine is here ").
But an ethical row has broken out on this new frontier. In June, the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics published guidelines arguing that people having their genome sequenced should be informed if the results show defects in any of 56 genes linked to 24 serious diseases (
Genetics in Medicine, vol 15, p 565).
The idea is to flag up known risks that could be mitigated – although in some cases that could require drastic action. The list includes mutations in the
BRCA1 gene that earlier this year prompted movie star
Angelina Jolie to have a double mastectomy to reduce her risk of developing breast cancer.
The intentions are laudable, but routine disclosure may not always be welcome. Imagine that you are seeking the cause of a mysterious condition that has brought your...
Related Articles
By Teddy Rosenbluth, The New York Times | 02.09.2026
Dr. Mehmet Oz has urged Americans to get vaccinated against measles, one of the strongest endorsements of the vaccine yet from a top health official in the Trump administration, which has repeatedly undermined confidence in vaccine safety.
Dr. Oz, the...
By Ava Kofman, The New Yorker | 02.09.2026
1. The Surrogates
In the delicate jargon of the fertility industry, a woman who carries a child for someone else is said to be going on a “journey.” Kayla Elliott began hers in February, 2024, not long after she posted...
By Alex Polyakov, The Conversation | 02.09.2026
Prospective parents are being marketed genetic tests that claim to predict which IVF embryo will grow into the tallest, smartest or healthiest child.
But these tests cannot deliver what they promise. The benefits are likely minimal, while the risks to...
By Lauren Hammer Breslow and Vanessa Smith, Bill of Health | 01.28.2026
On Jan. 24, 2026, the New York Times reported that DNA sequences contributed by children and families to support a federal effort to understand adolescent brain development were later co-opted by other researchers and used to publish “race science”...