Genetic Test for Autism Refuted
By Ed Yong,
The Scientist
| 10. 25. 2013
In September 2012, a team of Australian scientists
claimed to have developed a genetic test that predicts a person’s risk of developing autism spectrum disorder (ASD) with 72 percent accuracy. Writing in
Molecular Psychiatry, the team led by Stan Skafidis and Carlos Pantelis from the University of Melbourne said that their panel of 237 genetic markers could “correctly classify ASD from non-ASD individuals” and “may provide a tool for screening at birth or during infancy to provide an index of at-risk status.”
But a new study, led by
Benjamin Neale from Massachusetts General Hospital, suggests that those claims were overblown. Neale’s team replicated the Australian group’s research in a larger sample, and found that the proposed panel of markers did not accurately predict ASDs.
“The claims in the original manuscript were quite bold. If they were true, it really would have been quite a major advance for the field, with serious ramifications for patients and other risk populations,” said Neale. “I think it’s important to ensure that this kind of work is of the highest quality.”
“This is a...
Related Articles
By Philip Ball, Quanta Magazine | 06.18.2026
Since its molecular structure was deduced in the 1950s, DNA has been hailed by many biologists as the secret of life. They’ve read and studied the information stored in the DNA found in the cells of living organisms, known as...
By Nicholas Wade, The New York Times | 04.30.2026
“J. Craig Venter” via Wikimedia Commons licensed under CC by 2.5
J. Craig Venter, a scientist and entrepreneur who raced to decode the human genome, died on Wednesday in San Diego. He was 79.
His death was announced by...
By Jonathan Basile, Los Ángeles Review of Books | 04.29.2026
WILLIAM BATESON, a foundational figure in the science of genetics at the turn of the last century, once recounted the response of a Scottish soldier to one of his public lectures: “Sir, what ye’re telling us is nothing but Scientific...
By Alex Aylward, Daniel J. Fairbanks, Maria Kiladi, and Gregory Radick , Heredity | 04.20.2026
Genetics and eugenics co-evolved at the beginning of the twentieth century and remained associated through the 1940s and beyond. Early geneticists were far from unanimous in their views on eugenics; some avidly supported the movement, whereas others openly opposed it...