Prop. 71's fine print contains surprises: Tightly written law leaves little room for oversight or changes
By Bernadette Tansey,
San Francisco Chronicle
| 12. 08. 2004
The $3 billion stem cell initiative that passed overwhelmingly last month holds surprises for voters who didn't read it -- starting with a provision that the research money doesn't have to be spent on stem cell studies.
It's also not the case, contrary to campaign pitches for Proposition 71, that the $3 billion raised from state bonds won't cost the state anything for the first five years. Interest payments will begin immediately, paid out of the bond money itself -- meaning that tens to hundreds of millions of "research" dollars must be used to pay debt service.
And as lawmakers and critics have learned, if they find fault with the ballot initiative, changing it could be tough. Under the proposition's terms, the state Legislature can't modify the law for three years. Even then, it can do so only by a 70 percent vote of both houses and with the governor's approval.
Some laws are like a car patched together from spare parts, but the California Stem Cell Research and Cures Initiative is built like a tank. Lawyers involved in...
Related Articles
By Susan Dominus, The New York Times Magazine | 04.27.2026
Why are babies born young? The most natural phenomenon on earth is actually hard to explain — at least on a cellular level. Consider this problem: The components of conception are old. When a woman gets pregnant, she has...
By Alfonso Martinez Arias, Nicolas Rivron, and Naomi Moris, BioNews | 04.20.2026
By Emily Mullin, Wired | 04.23.2026
A STARTUP OUT of Utah, Paterna Biosciences, says it has successfully grown functional human sperm in a lab and used the sperm to make visibly healthy-looking embryos. The technique could eventually help men with certain types of infertility have biological children...
By Peter Ward, Slate | 03.30.2026
I’m in a cramped examination room at a clinic in Panama City. The lights are dim, and calming classical music plays from built-in speakers. A nurse has injected a dose of stem cells into Kenneth Scott through an IV in...