California and the Fourth Amendment
By Editorial,
The New York Times
| 09. 18. 2012
On Wednesday, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit is scheduled to reconsider whether California violates the Fourth Amendment’s prohibition against searches and seizures by requiring police to take DNA samples from people arrested but not yet convicted of felonies. California’s law is ostensibly aimed at accurately identifying those arrested, solving crimes and exonerating the innocent. It is also, unfortunately, unconstitutional.
An appeals court panel ruled otherwise in February. In a 2-to-1 vote, it said the law was reasonable, a view with prominent support. In July, Chief Justice John Roberts Jr. wrote that there was “a reasonable probability” that the Supreme Court would address the issue this term in a Maryland case and that there was “a fair prospect” that it would rule as the appeals court panel had in the California case. This is a matter of national import because the federal government and more than half the states have laws allowing DNA sampling before conviction.
The constitutional outcome should be clear. Unless there is a warrant, or suspicion of a different crime that a DNA...
Related Articles
By Neel Shah, The Preprint | 04.11.2024
Years ago, I interviewed for a residency position at The Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore. Standing before the domed Victorian building at the campus entrance, I couldn’t help but be in awe of the history of the place, the great...
By Sabrina Souza and Zoe Sottile, CNN | 04.01.2024
Michigan has become the last state to decriminalize paid surrogacy on Monday, after Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer signed a package of bills intended to protect families using surrogacy and in vitro fertilization (IVF).
Whitmer signed the Michigan Family Protection Act...
By Emily Cochrane, The New York Times | 04.03.2024
A Mobile, Ala., hospital at the center of a State Supreme Court ruling that found that frozen embryos could be considered children said on Wednesday that it would no longer provide in vitro fertilization lab services after this year.
In...
By Todd Feathers, The Guardian | 03.25.2024
For the last several months, a city at the heart of Silicon Valley has been training artificial intelligence to recognize tents and cars with people living inside in what experts believe is the first experiment of its kind in the...